Diogo Dalot avoided a dismissal after a high‑speed challenge on Jeremy Doku in the Manchester derby, with VAR deeming the tackle “mistimed” rather than a red‑card offence. United secured a 2‑0 victory thanks to goals from Marcus Rashford and Antony, while the incident reignited debate over Premier League disciplinary standards.
The Tackle That Sparked Debate
What Happened on the Pitch
Midway through the first half, Dalot slid into Doku, causing the winger to land on his thigh. The contact was clearly visible on replays, prompting immediate protests from the opposing bench and audible boos from the crowd.
VAR Decision and Premier League Explanation
After consulting VAR, officials concluded the challenge was a “mistimed challenge” and not “serious foul play.” The league’s panel noted the absence of intent to injure and classified the contact as “non‑violent,” therefore not meeting the threshold for a red card.
Reactions from Managers and Players
Manchester City’s View
City’s manager described the ruling as a “glaring miscarriage of justice,” warning that reckless challenges could go unpunished. The team’s captain added that penalties should match the severity when a player is put in danger.
United’s Perspective
United’s coach defended Dalot, emphasizing his importance to the defence and his willingness to learn. Dalot himself apologized for the mistimed challenge, expressing sympathy for Doku and respect for the officials’ decision.
Impact on Premier League Disciplinary Policy
Current Guidelines and Criticism
The league recently introduced a “three‑strike” policy intended to curb dangerous play while avoiding over‑penalisation of isolated incidents. Critics argue the policy creates uncertainty, causing referees to hesitate before issuing red cards.
Potential Changes Ahead
Analysts suggest the Dalot incident could trigger a review of the “serious foul play” definition. Consistency in enforcement is seen as essential to prevent perceptions that the rules favour protecting star players.
Match Outcome and Key Moments
United’s 2‑0 win was highlighted by Rashford’s opening goal and Antony’s second‑half strike. The match also featured Michael Carrick’s return to the coaching staff, adding a symbolic moment to the victory.
- Final Score: Manchester United 2 – 0 Manchester City
- Goal Scorers: Marcus Rashford, Antony
- Controversial Incident: Dalot’s challenge on Jeremy Doku
- Disciplinary Result: No further action taken against Dalot
